When horror sequels work, they deepen a film’s spooky lore, elevate fear, or even reinvent their franchise altogether. But when they fail, they remind audiences just how hard it is to recapture what made a great horror flick so awesome in the first place.

A great horror film can linger in the collective consciousness for decades — its atmosphere, performances, and themes becoming part of genre history, and even influencing countless other films and areas of pop culture.

But a poorly made sequel can unravel that legacy almost overnight. When studios rush to capitalize on a hit, the results can often trade artistry for profit, draining all the blood out of what made the original so haunting to begin with.

READ MORE: Great Movies That Were Ruined By Becoming Franchises

Baffling sequels such as The Exorcist II: The Heretic, American Psycho 2, and Book of Shadows: Blair Witch 2 are infamous examples of this unfortunate phenomenon. Each followed a groundbreaking, critically acclaimed, beloved film with a diluted continuation that misunderstood the tone, pacing, or purpose of its memorable predecessor.

Ultimately, a bad sequel doesn’t just disappoint fans — it can tarnish how the franchise is remembered by the public forever. These terrible horror sequels serve as cautionary tales rather than scary stories, and the message is frighteningly clear: Even the most iconic and capable horror franchises can’t survive on name recognition alone.