Ryan Seacrest tried something for the first time in his life, and his costars couldn’t believe what went wrong. The Wheel of Fortune host shared his debut spray tan disaster on his On Air radio show.

Ryan Seacrest just got his debut spray tan done

Ryan Seacrest shared on his On Air radio show that he tried his first-ever spray tan. The Wheel of Fortune host went to Sugared + Bronzed and selected a level two application. He confessed that nerves got the better of him and he decided to leave his face out.

His cohosts immediately spotted the issue with that choice. “Ohhh. Well, that’s why,” cohost Sisanie reacted, noting why no one could detect any change. Seacrest appeared genuinely confused that spray tans typically include the face. “Why would I do my face?” he questioned. “I don’t want that stuff on my face to cause a zit.”

The situation got worse when his cohosts discovered he had showered too soon afterward. Cohost Tanya Rad asked if he had waited the recommended six hours before showering. Seacrest responded with confusion, asking, “Before I did what?” Sisanie then declared to Rad, “100 percent. He went home and washed it all off within the hour.”

When Seacrest asked about fixing the uneven result, Sisanie laughed and suggested makeup. She also pointed out that his long sleeves hid any remaining color. The On Air with Ryan Seacrest Instagram account posted about the moment with the caption, “We’re gonna need to try this again.” The post quickly gained traction with fans.

Many viewers found it surprising that the longtime television personality had never tried a spray tan before. Seacrest has hosted major shows including American Idol and now Wheel of Fortune for years. Fans reacted with humor in the comments, while some expressed disappointment at the failed attempt.